Tested on the Same 316 Family Photos
Timeline Scan, the AI photo dating service, vs MyHeritage PhotoDater (2026)
We gave both the same 316 scanned prints, taken 1919 to 1990. Timeline Scan dated every one. PhotoDater put a year on 115.
By Spencer Baker, founder of Timeline Scan · Last updated: November 11, 2026 · tested November 9 and 10, 2026Quick answer
We tested both on the same 316 family photos from 1919 to 1990, fronts only. Timeline Scan dated all 316, with 94% of photo pairs in the right order and 99% within five years. MyHeritage PhotoDater put a year on 115, none after 1985. Even on the 115 it dated, Timeline Scan was closer: 99% vs 72% within five years.
- Every photo dated, with the date saved in the file? Timeline Scan (AI photo organizer).
- A free year guess on a photo already in a MyHeritage tree? PhotoDater, for photos with people taken 1860 to 1990[1]; the guess isn't saved in the file[2].
- Is it free? PhotoDater is, with a MyHeritage account[1]. Timeline Scan has a free trial, then per-photo pricing.
Head-to-head test
Same 316 Photos, Two Tools: the Results
Real scanned prints from our founder's family, taken 1919 to 1990, each with a known date from outside the picture. Both tools saw only the front of each print.
-
Photo pairs put in the right order
- Timeline Scan
- 94%
- PhotoDater
- 22%
-
Within five years of the true date
- Timeline Scan
- 99%
- PhotoDater
- 44%
-
Photos given a year
- Timeline Scan
- 316/316
- PhotoDater
- 115/316
Over all 316 photos. A photo with no estimate counts as a miss, the same rule as our accuracy page. We gave PhotoDater credit for “After 1985” whenever the photo was taken 1986 to 1990.
Timeline Scan dated every photo. PhotoDater named a year for about a third.
What each tool said about the 316 photos.
- Timeline Scan: a date
- PhotoDater: a year
- PhotoDater: “After 1985” only
- No estimate
PhotoDater only shows an estimate when it is confident enough[2]. Timeline Scan dates every photo you give it, and you can change any date.
Even on the photos PhotoDater chose to date, Timeline Scan was closer
Closer to the true date on 87 of those 115 photos, against 15 for PhotoDater, with 13 tied.
Photo pairs in the right order (6,349 pairs)
Within five years
Within one year
Typical miss on these photos: 1 year for Timeline Scan, 4 years for PhotoDater. PhotoDater's own figure is about 60% within five years[1].
Photo pairs in the right order (48,569 pairs)
Within five years
Within one year
A photo with no estimate can't be placed, so it counts as a miss. “After 1985” counts as right, even within a year, whenever the photo was taken 1986 to 1990.
Newer photos
PhotoDater Stops Naming Years After 1985
MyHeritage says PhotoDater covers 1860 to 1990[1]. In our test it never named a year later than 1985: newer photos got “After 1985” or no estimate. Timeline Scan dated every photo in every era.
What PhotoDater said, by the year each photo was taken
Each bar is one era's photos. Below it, how many each tool got within five years.
- A year
- “After 1985” only
- No estimate
Within 5 years: Timeline Scan 5 of 6, PhotoDater 1 of 6
Within 5 years: Timeline Scan 12 of 14, PhotoDater 7 of 14
Within 5 years: Timeline Scan 45 of 45, PhotoDater 28 of 45
Within 5 years: Timeline Scan 34 of 34, PhotoDater 25 of 34
Within 5 years: Timeline Scan 48 of 48, PhotoDater 22 of 48
Within 5 years: Timeline Scan 169 of 169, PhotoDater 57 of 169
122 of PhotoDater's 142 no-estimates were photos taken 1987 to 1990. Before 1970 we had only 20 photos, too few to rank either tool there.
Year guessed against year taken
Each dot is one of the 115 photos PhotoDater put a year on. A dot on the dashed diagonal is exactly right; the shaded band is within five years. Hover a dot for its dates.
PhotoDater 72% in the band
Timeline Scan 99% in the band
PhotoDater answered 1985 for 37 of its 115 photos, taken anywhere from 1976 to 1990, and its guesses ran early: 1.4 years on average.
From the test
Four of the 316 Photos
The true dates came from the back of the print or our family archive, and neither tool saw them. PhotoDater gives a year and how sure it is. When Timeline Scan spots one detail that dates a photo, it names it, as its app does.
-

1955Written on the back
- PhotoDater
- 196510 years late79% confident, ±6 years
- Timeline Scan
- June 1953Within 2 years
-

March 14, 1967Written on the back
- PhotoDater
- 19598 years early92% confident, ±5 years
- Timeline Scan
- March 1964Within 3 years
-

December 1978Written on the back
- PhotoDater
- 19857 years late77% confident, ±6 years
- Timeline Scan
- December 1978Right month
-

February 1987From our family archive
- PhotoDater
- 19834 years early85% confident, ±5 years
- Timeline Scan
- February 1987Right monthClue: “1987 registration sticker on side of Polaris TXL snowmobile”
Shown with the family's permission. Timeline Scan's answers are shown to the month. Every photo's full result, with its clue, is in the download below.
This test was fronts only
Scan the Back Too, and Timeline Scan Reads It
PhotoDater dates the picture alone[1], so Timeline Scan got only the fronts too. Family prints often say more on the back: a date, a name, a place. 230 of these 316 prints had a date or caption written on the back.
Saved in the front photo's file
- Date taken
- July 3, 1994
- Description
- “Spencer July 3, 1994”EXIF ImageDescription, IPTC Caption and XMP Description
-
More accurate
With a date on the front or back, our accuracy tests measured 98 to 100% of photo pairs in the right order and 99 to 100% within a year of the true date.
-
The words are kept
Timeline Scan transcribes the back and saves the note in the photo's own file, so a grandparent's names and places travel with the picture into Google Photos, Apple Photos or Immich.
-
Made for family historians
The caption becomes searchable and outlives the print. PhotoDater's estimates aren't saved in the file at all[2].
Check our work
How We Tested
- The photos. 316 scanned prints from our founder's family, taken 1919 to 1990. We kept only what PhotoDater is built for: people in the picture and no date printed on the front[2]. The set was fixed before either tool ran.
- The true dates come from outside the picture: 230 from a date or caption written on the back, checked against the front, and 86 from our family archive's earlier hand-checked dates. 95 are known to the day, 180 to the month and 41 to a year or a span of years.
- PhotoDater: each front was uploaded to a free MyHeritage account with its file metadata removed, since MyHeritage shows a date already in the file instead of estimating one[2]. Answers were recorded November 9 and 10, 2026. A photo counted as “no estimate” only after two clean checks.
- Timeline Scan: the same files, dated November 9, 2026 with the production dating model, fronts only and no faces named. Each album's photos went in together, in shuffled order, as when a customer uploads a box.
- Scoring by year, because PhotoDater answers in years. A guess inside the true date's year, or span of years, is 0 years off. Right order checks every two photos whose true dates don't overlap; a tie counts as half. Scored on its full dates instead of years, Timeline Scan put 95.8% of all pairs in the right order.
- Is the gap real? On the 115 photos PhotoDater dated, Timeline Scan was within five years on 31 that PhotoDater missed, and PhotoDater on none that Timeline Scan missed (exact McNemar test, p < 0.000001). Re-sampling the 10 source albums, Timeline Scan's lead in right order on those photos stayed between 13 and 27 points (95% range).
- Fair notes. Timeline Scan looks at each photo alongside the others in its upload, which is how the product works; PhotoDater looks at one photo at a time. The photos come from one family, and 217 of the 316 were taken 1986 to 1990, where PhotoDater stops naming years. Before 1970 we had only 20 photos: Timeline Scan was within five years on 17 and PhotoDater on 8, too few to rank. PhotoDater may change, so these are its results as tested on November 9 and 10, 2026.
316 rows: the true date span, each tool's answer, how many years off it was, and the clue Timeline Scan named. Photo IDs are anonymous; the family photos themselves stay private, apart from the four above.
Feature by feature
Timeline Scan vs PhotoDater: Comparison Table
Numbered citations point to MyHeritage's own blog and help center (sources).
| Feature | MyHeritage PhotoDater | Timeline Scan |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A free AI feature inside the MyHeritage genealogy website and mobile apps[1] | A done-for-you dating and organizing service, in your browser |
| Supported date range | LimitedPhotos taken between 1860 and 1990 only[1]; in our test, no year later than 1985 | Any eraOld scans and digital photos alike; our test covered 1919 to 1990 |
| Accuracy | Our test, same 316 photos: 44% within 5 years, or 72% of the 115 it put a year on (results)MyHeritage's own testing: ≈60% of estimates within 5 years[1] | Our test, same 316 photos, fronts only: 99% within 5 years and 94% of photo pairs in the right orderDated, front or back: 98 to 100% of photo pairs in the right order and 99 to 100% within a year of the true dateNo date anywhere: 96% within five years, >99% once family faces are tagged (methodology) |
| Writes the date into the photo file (EXIF/XMP)? | No“Date estimates are not automatically saved to the photo's metadata” and must be confirmed manually; confirmed dates live in your MyHeritage family site's data[2] | YesStandard EXIF/XMP capture-date fields where possible, so Google Photos, Apple Photos, Immich and Lightroom sort them |
| What it analyzes | The image itself: clothing, hairstyles, facial hair, furniture, and other period objects[1] | The image, handwriting on the backs, lab and camera dates, neighboring photos, and family details you share |
| Photos it will date | LimitedOnly photos taken before 1990 with people in them, and only when its confidence is high enough[1][2]. In our test: a year for 115 of 316 | Any photoAny era, with or without people, and it always gives an estimate: 316 of 316 in our test. You can adjust any date |
| Date precision | An estimated year, with a confidence level and error range shown on request[2] | A full date where clues allow, like a lab-printed “JUL 87” |
| Where your photos end up | Uploaded to and stored in your MyHeritage online family site[1] | Your computer, in six folder layouts; Google Photos or Immich |
| Batch handling | Estimates appear photo-by-photo as you view each photo page; each estimate is confirmed or rejected individually[2] | The whole collection at once, as one reviewable timeline |
| Price | FreeWith a MyHeritage account[1] | Free trial on 50 photos with no credit card, then per-photo pricing (see pricing) |
The honest recommendation
When Each Tool Is the Right Choice
Choose MyHeritage PhotoDater if…
- Your photos already live in a MyHeritage family tree
- They're from 1860–1990 and show people
- A free, on-screen year guess is all you need
- You're fine with no answer on many photos
It's free. In our test it put a year on 115 of 316 photos.
Choose Timeline Scan if…
- You want every photo dated: 316 of 316 in our test
- You want the whole collection organized: folders by year or Google Photos
- Your photos are from the late 1980s on, where PhotoDater stops naming years
- You want the handwriting on the backs read
- You want the date written into each file
- You'd rather it be done for you, not photo by photo
Try it free on 50 photos, no credit card.
Not either/or
Using Both? Run Timeline Scan First
MyHeritage reads dates already present in a photo's metadata; PhotoDater itself only estimates photos that don't have one[2].
-
Date your scans with Timeline Scan
Each file carries its corrected date.
-
Download them in folders by year
-
Upload copies to MyHeritage
They arrive already dated: no photo-by-photo confirming.
-
Let PhotoDater estimate any stragglers
Common questions
Timeline Scan vs PhotoDater: FAQ
How did PhotoDater do against Timeline Scan on the same photos?
We ran both on the same 316 scanned family photos taken 1919 to 1990, fronts only. Timeline Scan dated all 316: 94% of photo pairs in the right order and 99% within five years of the true date.
PhotoDater put a year on 115 photos, said only “After 1985” on 59 and gave no estimate on 142. Over all 316, PhotoDater put 22% of photo pairs in the right order and 44% within five years. On just the 115 photos it dated, PhotoDater was within five years on 72% and Timeline Scan on 99% (charts and method).
How accurate is MyHeritage PhotoDater?
In MyHeritage's own testing, about 60% of PhotoDater's estimates were within 5 years of the actual date the photo was taken[1].
In our same-photo test on 316 scanned family photos, 72% of the 115 years it gave were within 5 years; counting the photos it skipped as misses, 44% of all 316 were, against 99% for Timeline Scan on the same fronts.
It only estimates photos taken between 1860 and 1990 that include people, and only when its confidence is high enough; otherwise no estimate is shown[2].
Why does PhotoDater skip so many photos?
PhotoDater only shows an estimate when it is confident enough, and only for photos with people taken 1860 to 1990[2].
In our test it never named a year later than 1985: newer photos got “After 1985” or no estimate, and 122 of its 142 no-estimates were photos taken 1987 to 1990. Timeline Scan dates every photo you give it, and you can change any date.
Does MyHeritage PhotoDater write the date into my photo files?
No. MyHeritage's help center states that date estimates “are not automatically saved to the photo's metadata” and must be confirmed manually; confirmed dates are stored in your MyHeritage family site's data rather than inside the photo file[2].
Timeline Scan does the opposite: it writes the corrected date into each file's standard EXIF/XMP capture-date fields where possible, so the photos sort correctly in Google Photos, Apple Photos, Immich and other metadata-aware apps.
Can PhotoDater date photos taken after 1990 or before 1860?
No. MyHeritage states that PhotoDater provides date estimates only for undated photos taken between 1860 and 1990[1]. Timeline Scan has no era restriction: it reads the dates already inside recent digital photos and estimates older scans from handwriting on the backs, printed lab dates, visual clues and neighboring photos.
Is MyHeritage PhotoDater free?
Yes. MyHeritage describes PhotoDater as completely free[1]; you need a MyHeritage account and your photos must be uploaded to MyHeritage. Timeline Scan offers a free trial on 50 photos with no credit card, then charges per photo dated; see the pricing page.
Which is better for organizing scanned family photos: PhotoDater or Timeline Scan?
They do different jobs. PhotoDater is best if your photos already live in a MyHeritage family tree and you want free, on-screen year estimates for genealogy research.
Timeline Scan is best if you want your whole collection dated and organized as files you keep: it writes dates into each photo's metadata and returns the collection in folders by year, or delivers it to Google Photos or Immich.
Can I use Timeline Scan and MyHeritage PhotoDater together?
Yes, and order matters. Run your scans through Timeline Scan first so each file carries its corrected date in standard metadata, then upload to MyHeritage.
MyHeritage reads dates already present in a photo's metadata, and PhotoDater itself notes it only estimates photos without one[2]. So your family-site photos arrive dated instead of needing photo-by-photo confirmation.
Show your work
Sources
The 3 MyHeritage sources
- MyHeritage Blog: “Introducing PhotoDater™: Find Out When Old Photos Were Taken” (August 2023). States the 1860–1990 range, the “approximately 60% … within 5 years” test result, the clothing/hairstyle/object clues the model uses, and that the feature is free.
- MyHeritage Help Center: “What is PhotoDater™ and how does it work?” (accessed November 10, 2026). States that estimates are calculated only for photos without a metadata date that include people, that estimates are not automatically saved to the photo's metadata and need manual confirmation, and describes the confidence/error-range display.
- MyHeritage Blog: “PhotoDater™ Now Available on the MyHeritage and Reimagine Mobile Apps” (November 2023).
MyHeritage® and PhotoDater™ are trademarks of MyHeritage Ltd. Timeline Scan is an independent service and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by MyHeritage.
PhotoDater details on this page were checked against MyHeritage's public materials on November 10, 2026; our test results are as tested on November 9 and 10, 2026. Out of date? Tell us and we'll correct it.
See Your Own Photos Dated, Free
Start with 50 free photos, no credit card. Watch your own scans land in the right years, dates written into the files.
Try 50 Photos Free